Presenting Options: Good, Better, Best
From Client Experience: In our Definitive Guide to Working with Clients, we introduced the design process. This article covers presenting options.
Why Three Options, Not One
A single-price proposal forces the client into a binary decision: yes or no. Two options create a cheap-vs-expensive comparison where price dominates. Three options create a spectrum where the client chooses a level of investment — and the psychology consistently drives selection toward the middle.
This is not a gimmick. It is a framework that respects the client's autonomy while guiding them toward the option that delivers the best combination of visual impact and value. The middle tier should always be the project you would put in your portfolio — the design you are genuinely proud of. Price it so that most clients self-select into it.
Industry data across residential services consistently shows that 55-65% of clients choose the middle tier, 20-25% choose the top tier, and 15-20% choose the base tier. If your numbers look different, your tiers are probably not differentiated clearly enough.
Designing Each Tier
Good: The Professional Foundation
This is your entry-level offering, but it should never look cheap. Good is the package for the client who values a clean, professional result but is not ready for the full investment.
Typical scope: Front-facing roofline only. Warm white C9 LED on 12-inch spacing. Professional-grade clips, commercial wire, timer setup. Installation and removal included.
Design the Good tier so it stands alone. If a client chooses Good and sees the result on opening night, they should think "that looks great" — not "that looks incomplete." A clean roofline with consistent spacing and no visible shortcuts is a better calling card than a cluttered full-property job.
Pricing: Your minimum viable project cost. This must cover your overhead, crew time, materials, and margin. If Good does not make you money, raise the price or reduce the scope. You cannot subsidize Good with Better/Best profits — that math collapses when 20% of clients choose Good.
Better: Your Recommended Design
This is the heart of your proposal. Design it as if the client said "make my house look great" with no budget constraint. Then price it at a level that most clients can reach.
Typical scope: Full front roofline plus two to three accent features. Common additions: entry columns or doorframe, one signature tree, window outlines, or garage door framing. The specific additions depend on what the property offers — use what you identified during the consultation walk-through.
The key differentiator between Good and Better is depth. Good is a single layer — the roofline. Better adds a second layer — the accents — which creates the dimensional quality that makes a display photograph well and feel intentional rather than minimal.
Pricing: 40-60% above Good. This range is wide because the specific additions vary by property. A $2,000 Good tier with a $3,200 Better tier (60% uplift) works if Better includes a significant tree wrap. A $2,000 Good with a $2,800 Better (40% uplift) works if Better adds columns and a doorframe — smaller additions, smaller delta.
Best: The Full Experience
Best exists to serve two purposes: it captures the clients who genuinely want everything, and it makes Better look like a reasonable middle ground.
Typical scope: Full property treatment. Roofline on all visible sides, accent features on every major architectural element, landscape lighting (trees, pathway, garden beds), and possibly specialty elements like color-changing zones, animated sequences, or a custom feature (lit archway, lighted star, roof-mounted display).
Do not design Best as "Better plus a few things." Make it a distinctly different experience. If Better is the restaurant equivalent of a great entree, Best is the tasting menu with wine pairing. The client should look at Best and think "that is a show" — not "that is the same thing with a little more."
Pricing: 80-120% above Good. A $2,000 Good tier puts Best at $3,600-$4,400. A $3,000 Good tier puts Best at $5,400-$6,600. If your Best tier approaches $10,000+, make sure the scope justifies it — at that level, clients expect a genuinely transformative display.
The Proposal Document
Present all three options in a single document. Side-by-side comparison is critical — the client needs to see the differences visually, not flip between separate pages.
For each tier, include:
-
A name. "Classic Roofline," "Signature Collection," and "Estate Package" communicate more than Good/Better/Best. Choose names that match your brand.
-
A visual reference. A rendering, a marked-up nighttime photo, or a photo of a comparable installation. Clients cannot visualize "C9 warm white on 12-inch spacing with entry accents." They need to see it. Even a rough photo markup showing lit areas in yellow highlight is better than text alone.
-
A plain-language scope description. "Warm white LED roofline lighting along the entire front face (185 linear feet), professional clips, timer setup, one mid-season check, and removal in January" is clear. "C9 WW LED, SPT-2, 12" OC, 185 LF, AI/AO clips, TI-15 timer" is not — save the technical spec for your crew sheet.
-
What is included. Product, installation labor, timer/controller, one maintenance check, removal labor. Spell it out.
-
What is not included. Electrical repairs, structural repairs, additional service calls, damage from acts of nature. Spell this out too — it prevents disputes.
-
The price. One number per tier. Do not itemize materials vs. labor for the client — that invites them to question your margins. Present a project price.
Presentation Mechanics
In person is always better than email. When you present in person, you control the pace, you can read reactions, and you can answer questions in real time. If the client's face changes when they see the Best price, you can immediately redirect: "That top tier is for the clients who want the full show — most people find the Signature Collection hits the sweet spot."
If presenting by email, use a clean PDF (not a Word doc). Include a brief cover message: "Here are the three options we discussed at the consultation. I have included a visual for each so you can see what the result looks like. My recommendation is the Signature Collection — it gives your property the depth and dimension that really sets it apart from the street. Happy to jump on a call to walk through any questions."
Respond to questions within 2 hours during business hours. The proposal is the moment of highest client engagement. Delay kills momentum. If a client emails at 2 PM on Tuesday asking about the difference between Better and Best, and you respond Thursday, they have already moved on emotionally.
When Clients Want to Customize
Some clients will want to mix elements: "Can I get the Better roofline with just one tree from the Best tier?" The answer is always yes, with a custom price. Do not force clients into rigid tiers — the tiers are a framework for presenting options, not a menu with no substitutions.
Have a system for pricing add-ons. Keep a reference sheet with your per-element pricing: tree wrap ($350-$800 depending on size), column wraps ($150-$250 per pair), window outlines ($100-$175 each), pathway lighting ($15-$25 per stake). When a client asks to add a tree to the Better tier, you can quote it on the spot: "Adding the blue spruce to the Signature Collection would bring the total to $3,550. Want me to update the proposal?"
Key Takeaways
- Three tiers shift the client's decision from "yes or no" to "which level." The middle tier captures 55-65% of clients when differentiated correctly.
- Design Good so it stands alone with dignity. Design Better as your portfolio piece. Design Best as a distinctly different, show-stopping experience.
- Every tier needs a visual reference — rendering, photo markup, or comparable installation photo. Text descriptions do not sell lighting.
- Present a single project price per tier, not itemized materials and labor. Include a clear list of what is and is not covered.
- Allow customization. The tiers are a framework, not a rigid menu. Have add-on pricing ready so you can quote modifications on the spot.
What's Next
With options chosen, setting clear expectations prevents disappointment.
Next: Setting Expectations: Timeline & Results